You: I don't see any problem with an infinite series of events. We can imagine that time extends both backwards and forwards forever without believing it to be impossible.

Aaron: We can imagine what ever we wish but that does not make it so. In fact, time does not extend backwards forever but started when God created the universe.

You: How can you say that? God had to exist before the universe did in order for him to have a "when" in that to create the universe.

Aaron: On the contrary, time has no meaning for God.

How do you respond?

  1. "Time has no meaning" has no meaning. Go
  2. Creation implies action over time. Go