You: Are you saying, then, that non-wonderful, even disgusting, things are also evidence of God's plan.

Aaron: I suppose I am. They are all part of the wonderful whole that is the world around us.

You: Then there is no way that we could prove his plan does not exist. Good things prove it is there, as do bad things; where could we possibly find contrary evidence?

Aaron: This is exactly my point! Everything is evidence for God's plan. I do not wish to prove that it does not exist, but to prove that it does exist, and doing so is easy for evidence is all around us.

How do you respond?

  1. This argument must remain scientific. Go
  2. Then I can prove that my flying mother-in-law exists. Go