You: If you are going to make an extraordinary claim, then you are going to have to back it up with extraordinary proof. I could claim that I saw a six-foot-tall walking column of rosebuds and nobody would believe me, no matter how trustworthy I were otherwise.

Aaron: That is neither here nor there. The claim that God exists is not extraordinary in any way. Many people already accept his existence without proof.

How do you respond?

  1. People also accept the existence of UFOs and Bigfoot. Go
  2. It is an extraordinary claim. Go