You: Yes, but we cannot judge what is the right and wrong without knowing what the truth is in the first place. What is the point you are trying to make?

Aaron: The point is that there is a correct answer to the question "Do you believe in God" so any answer is either right or a wrong.

You: True, but that does not imply that I can find out what the right answer is.

Aaron: But if you can be sure there is a right answer, you should do your best to form an opinion on the subject. Let me elaborate.