You: That is certainly a very interesting argument, and I admit that I would never have thought of it myself, but it is not particularly strong. My biggest objection is to your assumption that there must be justice, or at least a balance of good and evil. How can you justify this statement?

Aaron is visibly shaken by your statement.

Aaron: Oh, my, what a strange thought. Of course there must be justice. If there is no justice, either in this world or in the next, then there is no hope to be had.

How do you respond?

  1. Hope does not necessarily exist. Go
  2. There is always hope. Go
  3. With God, there is no hope, only certainty. Go
  4. Hope has nothing to do with justice. Go