You: There are many more than two choices. History has accounts of hundreds of belief systems and thousands of gods, how do I decide which one or ones to put my faith in?

Aaron: You should put your faith in Christian God because he is the one true God and allow your sins to be forgiven through our Lord Jesus Christ. That is the only path to heaven.

You: You have not proven to me that there is any god, let alone that yours is superior to all others. I cannot choose to believe in any god, no matter how strongly you believe that I should.