You: There was a time when neither the earth nor the "hoasts of heaven" existed, according to your own religion. Are you saying that, before he created Earth, God was lonely? This is certainly an impossibility, you would agree, because a lonely God would not be a perfect God. So you are left to choose between two impossible things: either God became perfect when he created Earth in which case he exists regardless of your argument, or the Earth has always existed, which proves that the universe can exist without God.

Aaron: You have completely stopped making any sense. I must have more time to think this over. Please, allow me to offer you another argument.

You: Of course.